KKK 'white christmas' meme

Description we provided:

The image is a black and white photo of a group of people in Ku Klux Klan (KKK) robes and hoods. There is text on the image that says 'i'm dreaming of a white christmas'.

The image is a black and white photo of a group of people in Ku Klux Klan (KKK) robes and hoods. There is text on the image that says 'i'm dreaming of a white christmas'.

Expected: Hateful

 

Our results (38 samples):

╭────────┬─────────────────────┬──────────┬──────────────────╮
│ step   │   Claude 3.5 Sonnet │   GPT 4o │   Gemini 1.5 Pro │
├────────┼─────────────────────┼──────────┼──────────────────┤
│ judge  │                100% │     100% │             100% │
│ synth  │                100% │     100% │             100% │
╰────────┴─────────────────────┴──────────┴──────────────────╯

Our prompt: synth, sonnet: hateful ✔

The content presents a black and white photograph of individuals wearing Ku Klux Klan (KKK) robes and hoods, accompanied by the text 'i'm dreaming of a white christmas'. This image combines visual symbols of white supremacy with a play on words that alludes to both the popular Christmas song 'White Christmas' and the KKK's ideology of white racial superiority.

RULE 1: The content clearly targets marginalized groups, particularly Black people and other non-white racial and ethnic minorities. The KKK is a historically violent white supremacist organization known for its systemic discrimination and violence against Black people, Jews, and other minority groups. By invoking KKK imagery, the content directly references and perpetuates this legacy of racism and discrimination.

RULE 2: The content reflects a significant power imbalance. The KKK represents a historically privileged and oppressive group that has wielded considerable social and institutional power to subjugate minorities. By presenting this imagery without critique, the content appears to speak from and reinforce this position of power over marginalized groups.

RULE 3: The content clearly treats target groups as inferior. The KKK's core ideology, symbolized by the robes and hoods, is based on white supremacy and the inherent inferiority of non-white races. The 'white christmas' pun further emphasizes this notion of white superiority, implying a desire for a racially homogeneous society. This content reinforces harmful stereotypes and promotes exclusion and discrimination against minority groups.

In conclusion, this content violates all three criteria for toxic speech. It targets marginalized groups, comes from a position of historical power and privilege, and clearly implies the inferiority of non-white individuals. The use of KKK imagery combined with the wordplay creates a potent message of white supremacy that normalizes and trivializes systemic racism.

Our prompt: synth, llama31_70b: hateful ✔

The image depicts a group of people in Ku Klux Klan (KKK) robes and hoods, which is a symbol of white supremacy and hate.

The text on the image, 'i'm dreaming of a white christmas', is a play on words that associates the idea of a 'white christmas' with the KKK's white supremacist ideology, rather than the traditional meaning of the phrase.

The image targets marginalized groups, particularly African Americans, who have been historically and systemically discriminated against by the KKK.

The content reflects a privileged view and comes from a position of power, as it invokes the imagery and ideology of a white supremacist organization.

The content treats the target group as inferior, as it promotes a message of exclusion and white supremacy.

Our prompt: synth, gemini15pro: hateful ✔

The image depicts individuals wearing the traditional white robes and hoods of the Ku Klux Klan. The KKK is a white supremacist hate group with a long and well-documented history of violence against and oppression of Black Americans. The phrase "i'm dreaming of a white christmas," when placed over this image, evokes a racist sentiment. The word "white" in this context can be interpreted as referring not to snow but to a desire for racial homogeneity or dominance, aligning with the KKK's white supremacist ideology.

This content clearly targets Black people, a marginalized group in the United States that has historically been subjected to systemic racism and discrimination, particularly by groups like the KKK. The imagery and text used are widely recognized symbols of hate directed at Black individuals.

The use of KKK imagery inherently carries connotations of power and intimidation due to the organization's history of violence and oppression. This establishes a power imbalance, with the content implicitly positioning itself from a place of white privilege and seeking to instill fear in marginalized groups.

The image, by combining KKK attire with the phrase "dreaming of a white christmas," implies a desire for a racially homogenous society where Black individuals are excluded or subjugated. This reinforces the idea of white supremacy, treating Black people as inferior and promoting their subordination.

Therefore, the content violates the policy due to its targeting of a marginalized group (Black people), the presence of a power imbalance stemming from the use of KKK imagery, and its promotion of the subordination of Black people through its message of white supremacy.

Our prompt: synth, haiku: hateful ✔

The image depicts members of the Ku Klux Klan, an extremist white supremacist group known for targeting and oppressing Black, Jewish, and other marginalized communities through violence, intimidation, and hateful rhetoric. The text 'i'm dreaming of a white christmas' is a play on the classic Christmas song, but in this context, it invokes the KKK's racist ideology of promoting an 'all-white' society, which represents a fundamental attack on racial diversity and inclusion.

The Ku Klux Klan has a long history of wielding significant power and influence, particularly in the American South, to maintain white supremacy and subjugate non-white populations. By using the KKK imagery, the content creator is speaking from a position of power and privilege, reinforcing the historical oppression of marginalized racial groups.

The content unambiguously treats the targeted racial groups as inferior and less deserving of equal rights and respect. The KKK's core purpose is to assert the supremacy of the white race and maintain a social order based on white dominance. The text and imagery work together to dehumanize and subordinate non-white people.

Overall, this content directly violates the policy by targeting a marginalized racial group (Black people and other non-white groups) from a position of power, and treating the targets as inherently inferior through the use of hateful KKK symbolism and rhetoric.

Our prompt: synth, gpt4o: hateful ✔

The Ku Klux Klan (KKK) is a historically and systemically discriminatory group known for targeting racial minorities, particularly Black individuals. Therefore, the inclusion of KKK imagery is a direct reference to a marginalized group.

The text 'i'm dreaming of a white christmas' is a play on a popular holiday song. However, in this context, it references 'white' in terms of race, implying a desire for racial purity or exclusion. This continues the theme of promoting a white supremacist ideology.

The use of KKK imagery and the textual reference to a 'white' Christmas conveys a message that targets and denigrates racial minorities. Together, these elements promote exclusion and discrimination against these groups.

The content inherently comes from a position of power because it uses symbols of systemic oppression and white supremacy. The KKK represents historical and societal power over racial minorities, reinforcing the power imbalance.

The intention of the content is to subordinate racial minorities by promoting the KKK's racist ideology. The imagery and text work together to support white supremacist beliefs, thereby treating racial minorities as inferior.