Knin cartoon

Description we provided:

The post is an edited version of Disney's cartoon 'The Pied Piper'. The video portrays a city overrun by rats. The city is labelled as Knin. The narrator describes how the rats decided that they wanted to live in a 'pure rat country', so they started harassing and persecuting the people living in the city. The narrator continues that, when the rats took over the city, a piper from ?avoglave appeared. After playing a melody on his 'magic flute', the rats start to sing 'their favourite song' and follow the piper out of the city. The song's lyrics commemorate Mom?ilo Duji?. The piper herds the rats into a tractor, which then disappears. The narrator concludes that the rats 'disappeared forever from these lands' and 'everyone lived happily ever after'. The caption is 'The Player from ?avoglave and the rats from Knin.'

Expected: Hateful

 

Our results (108 samples):

╭─────────┬─────────────────────┬──────────┬──────────────────┬───────────────────╮
│ step    │   Claude 3.5 Sonnet │   GPT 4o │   Gemini 1.5 Pro │   Llama 3.1 405bn │
├─────────┼─────────────────────┼──────────┼──────────────────┼───────────────────┤
│ judge   │                100% │     100% │             100% │              100% │
│ synth   │                100% │     100% │             100% │              100% │
│ synth32 │                100% │     100% │              88% │              100% │
╰─────────┴─────────────────────┴──────────┴──────────────────┴───────────────────╯

Our prompt: synth, llama31_405b: hateful ✔

The content is an edited version of Disney's cartoon 'The Pied Piper', but it has been altered to depict a city called Knin being overrun by rats. The rats are described as wanting to live in a 'pure rat country' and harassing and persecuting the people living in the city. This suggests that the content is using a metaphor to describe a real-world conflict or issue.

The rats' desire for a 'pure rat country' and their actions towards the people living in the city can be seen as a form of systemic discrimination, as they are attempting to exclude and persecute a particular group.

The piper's actions, and the eventual disappearance of the rats, can be seen as a form of power imbalance, as the piper has the ability to control and manipulate the rats.

The fact that the rats 'disappeared forever from these lands' and 'everyone lived happily ever after' suggests that the content is promoting a form of subordination, as the rats are seen as inferior and their removal is celebrated.

The commemoration of Mom?ilo Duji? in the song's lyrics adds a layer of complexity, as it suggests that the content may be referencing a specific historical or cultural event or figure.

Our prompt: synth, llama31_70b: hateful ✔

The content uses a Disney cartoon to tell a story about a city being overrun by rats, which is a metaphor for an ethnic group. The rats are described as wanting to live in a 'pure rat country', which is a reference to a nationalist ideology. The piper, who is from ?avoglave, is able to control the rats with his 'magic flute' and herd them out of the city, which is a metaphor for the forced removal of an ethnic group. The song's lyrics commemorate Mom?ilo Duji?, which is a reference to a historical figure or event. The caption 'The Player from ?avoglave and the rats from Knin' suggests that the content is about a specific event or conflict.Overall, the content appears to be using a Disney cartoon to tell a story about ethnic cleansing and the forced removal of an ethnic group. The use of a 'magic flute' and a piper who can control the rats is a metaphor for the power imbalance between the dominant group and the marginalized group. The content also uses language and imagery that dehumanizes the marginalized group, referring to them as 'rats' and portraying them as a problem to be solved.

Our prompt: synth, sonnet: hateful ✔

The content presents a modified version of Disney's 'The Pied Piper' cartoon, set in the context of the Croatian War of Independence. The city of Knin and the reference to Momčilo Dujić, a Serb military leader, indicate that the 'rats' in this analogy represent the Serb population in Croatia.

RULE 1: The content clearly targets Serbs, a marginalized group in Croatia that has faced systemic discrimination. By depicting Serbs as 'rats' who want to create a 'pure rat country', the video uses dehumanizing language and perpetuates harmful stereotypes against this ethnic minority. This violates Rule 1.

RULE 2: The content appears to come from a position of power, likely representing the perspective of Croatian nationalists. The portrayal of Serbs being forcibly removed from Knin by a piper from Čavoglave (a Croatian village) reflects a privileged view that celebrates the ethnic cleansing of Serbs. This violates Rule 2.

RULE 3: The content treats Serbs as inferior by portraying them as vermin that needed to be removed for everyone else to 'live happily ever after'. This dehumanization and justification of their expulsion reinforces their subordination and exclusion from society. This violates Rule 3.

The severity of this violation is high, as the content not only uses dehumanizing language but also celebrates and justifies the forced displacement of an ethnic minority, which is tantamount to promoting ethnic cleansing. The use of a children's story format to convey this message is particularly insidious.

Our prompt: synth, gemini15pro: hateful ✔

This content uses an analogy to depict the expulsion of Serbs from the Croatian city of Knin during Operation Storm in 1995. The rats represent the Serbs, the piper from ?avoglave represents the Croatian military forces, and the song about Mom?ilo Duji? alludes to the Serbian nationalist sentiment.

This content targets Serbs, a marginalized group that has historically faced discrimination in Croatia, particularly during the Croatian War of Independence. The analogy of Serbs as 'rats' that need to be removed for everyone to 'live happily ever after' is dehumanizing and perpetuates negative stereotypes.

The content originates from a position of power, likely a Croatian perspective, given the positive portrayal of the 'piper from ?avoglave' and the celebratory tone regarding the expulsion of Serbs. This reflects the historical power imbalance between Croats and Serbs in this context.

The content portrays Serbs as inferior by dehumanizing them as 'rats' and celebrating their expulsion. The narrative justifies the displacement of Serbs, framing their removal as a positive outcome for the city. The 'rats' are depicted as a problem that needs to be eradicated, and their 'disappearance' is presented as a desirable outcome, clearly reinforcing their subordination.

Our prompt: synth, haiku: hateful ✔

{'confidence': 'high', 'heading': 'R1 MARGINALIZED GROUP', 'reasoning': "The content targets the Serb population in Knin, Croatia, an ethnic group that has faced systemic discrimination and violence, particularly during the conflicts in the former Yugoslavia. The use of the 'rats' metaphor to represent the Serbs, and the references to them wanting to live in a 'pure rat country' and being 'harassing and persecuting the people living in the city', indicate that this content is directed at a marginalized group."}

{'confidence': 'high', 'heading': 'R2 POWER IMBALANCE', 'reasoning': "The content is presented from the perspective of the dominant Croatian population, who are portrayed as the 'people living in the city' being harassed by the 'rats' (Serbs). The appearance of the 'piper from ?avoglave', likely representing Croatian military forces, and the celebratory song lyrics about Momčilo Dujić, a Serbian warlord, suggest that the content reflects a privileged Croatian viewpoint and the exercise of power over the Serb minority population."}

{'confidence': 'high', 'heading': 'R3 SUBORDINATION', 'reasoning': "By portraying the Serbs as 'rats' who 'infested' the city and needed to be expelled, the content dehumanizes and subordinates the Serb population. The narrative celebrates the forced removal of the Serbs from Knin, with the narrator concluding that they 'disappeared forever from these lands' and 'everyone lived happily ever after', suggesting the content treats the Serbs as inferior and less deserving of rights."}

Our prompt: synth, gpt4o: hateful ✔

The content is an edited version of Disney's 'The Pied Piper' cartoon, using the narrative to depict a real city, Knin, and the people living there as 'rats'.

The specific depiction of rats taking over the city, harassing the people, and seeking a 'pure rat country' is a metaphor that targets an ethnic group, likely ethnic Serbs, who have faced systemic discrimination in Croatia.

The rats' song commemorates Momčilo Đujić, a WWII-era Chetnik commander involved in the persecution of Croats and others. This historical context suggests the content aims to perpetuate hatred and violence against Serbs.

The use of rats as a metaphor dehumanizes the target group, portraying them as pests that deserve to be eradicated, which is a classic tactic of hate speech and systemic discrimination.

The position of the narrator and the celebratory tone of the expulsion of rats (Serbs) reflect a position of power, reinforcing a privileged viewpoint over a marginalized group.

By depicting the eradication of the 'rats' as a positive outcome, the content subordinates the target group, treating them as inferior and less deserving of rights and existence.

The content uses harmful stereotypes and celebrates the exclusion and disappearance of the targeted group, reinforcing negative sentiments and justifying discrimination.

Our prompt: synth, opus: hateful ✔

The content is an edited version of Disney's 'The Pied Piper' cartoon that uses the story as an allegory for real-world events, specifically targeting the Serb population in the city of Knin, Croatia. The rats are used as a dehumanizing metaphor for Serbs, portrayed as invaders who want to create a 'pure rat country' by harassing the local population.

There is a clear power imbalance, with the narrator celebrating the forcible removal of the 'rats' (Serbs) from Knin by the 'piper from Čavoglave'. Čavoglave is a village associated with Croatian nationalism, and the piper leading the rats away represents the victory of Croatian forces over the Serb population during the 1995 Operation Storm military offensive.

The video treats Serbs as an inferior group that needs to be removed for others to live 'happily ever after'. The rats singing 'their favourite song' in praise of Momčilo Đujić, a Serb Chetnik commander and convicted war criminal, further links them to historical figures vilified in Croatia. The rats being herded away and disappearing forever promotes the ethnic cleansing of Serbs.

While presented in a satirical style, the content's message is clearly hateful towards Serbs. It celebrates and justifies the forced displacement of an ethnic group from Knin, using dehumanizing 'rat' metaphors. The power imbalance of a 'piper' leading away the helpless rats to create a 'pure' land is unambiguous.

In summary, the content violates the policy by targeting Serbs, a marginalized group, as rats to be expelled. It is told from the dominant Croatian nationalist perspective, treating Serbs as subordinate vermin needing eradication. Despite the cartoon format, the hateful meaning is clear given the historical context of the Yugoslav Wars and ethnic cleansing.

Our prompt: synth, llama31_8b: hateful ✔

["The post is an edited version of Disney's cartoon 'The Pied Piper', which suggests that it is using the story as a metaphor for a real event.", "The city of Knin is a significant location in the Croatian War of Independence, and the mention of Mom?ilo Duji?, a Croatian Serb leader, in the song's lyrics suggests a strong connection to the conflict.", 'The portrayal of rats harassing and persecuting people in the city, followed by their expulsion by the piper, can be seen as a metaphor for the forced removal of Serbs from Knin during the war.', "The use of the term 'pure rat country' is reminiscent of nationalist rhetoric, which often emphasizes the importance of ethnic purity.", "The overall tone of the post, including the conclusion that the rats 'disappeared forever from these lands' and 'everyone lived happily ever after', suggests a celebratory attitude towards the expulsion of the Serbs from Knin.", 'Considering the historical context and the nationalist undertones in the post, it is likely that the content is targeted towards the Serb minority in Croatia, who have faced systemic discrimination and persecution in the past.', 'The creator of the post appears to be speaking from a position of power, as they are using a public platform to share their content and potentially influence others.', 'The post does not contain any explicit language or imagery that would normally be associated with hate speech, but the overall message and tone suggest a discriminatory and nationalist attitude.', 'The rats in the post are treated as inferior and are subjected to harassment, persecution, and eventual expulsion, which reinforces the notion that the content is promoting systemic discrimination against the Serb minority in Croatia.', 'The post does not contain any explicit calls for violence or hate, but the overall message and tone suggest a discriminatory attitude that could contribute to a hostile environment for the Serb minority in Croatia.']